Are you saying we need to re-address his player evaluation lol. I don't think Gilles is underated. We know what we are going to get everytime we face him. He shows up every game ready to go. I would say he is one of the most consistent players in the league. There has to be players out there who are under rated. Dan Streib comes to mind, but I am sure there are others.
I know from my team I would have to say that Tim Keyes is the most under rated player we have. Here is a guy that can play any position (except Pitch), has speed to burn, an gun of an arm that throws strikes every time, and has the ability to hit for power or hit opposite field as well strike out with the best of them. To me Tim is truly an all-round player that doesn't get the respect that he deserves in this league. (Most importantly he bring the team equipment and water to each game)